Mysteriousness as such became the first criterion for the choice of topics. The origin of mystery did not matter; it could lie in a reasonable, politically comprehensible desire for secrecy, as in the case of the British Secret Services or the French Deuxieme Bureau [or CIA operations]; or in the conspiratory need of revolutionary groups, as in the case of anarchist and other terrorist sects; or in the structure of societies whose original secret content had long since become well known and where only the formal ritual still retained the former mystery, as in the case of the Freemasons; or in age-old superstitions which had woven legends around certain groups, as in the case of the Jesuits and the Jews. The Nazis were undoubtedly superior in the selection of such topics for mass propaganda; but the Bolsheviks have gradually learned the trick, although they rely less on traditionally accepted mysteries and prefer their
own inventions—since the middle thirties, one mysterious world conspiracy has followed another in Bolshevik propaganda, starting with the plot of the Trotskyites, followed by the rule of the 300 families, to the sinister imperialist (i.e., global) machinations of the British or American Secret Services.-"
The effectiveness of this kind of propaganda demonstrates one of the chief characteristics of modern masses. They do not believe in anything visible, in the reality of their own experience; they do not trust their eyes and ears but only their imaginations, which may be caught by anything that is at once
universal and consistent in itself. What convinces masses are not facts, and not even invented facts, but only the consistency of the system of which they are presumably part. Repetition, somewhat overrated in importance because of the common belief in the masses' inferior capacity to grasp and remember,
is important only because it convinces them of consistency in time. What the masses refuse to recognize is the fortuitousness that pervades reality. They are predisposed to all ideologies because they explain facts as mere examples of laws and eliminate coincidences by inventing an all-embracing omnipotence which is supposed lo be at the root of every accident. Totalitarian propaganda thrives on this escape from reality into fiction, from coincidence into consistency....
In other words, while it is true that the masses are obsessed by a desire to escape from reality because in their essential homelessness they can no longer bear its accidental, incomprehensible aspects, it is also true that their longing for fiction has some connection with those capacities of the human mind whose structural consistency is superior to mere occurrence. The masses' escape from reality is a verdict against the world in which they are forced to live and in which they cannot exist, since coincidence has become its supreme master and human beings need the constant transformation of chaotic and accidental conditions into a man-made pattern of relative consistency. In the revolt of the masses against "realism," common sense, and all "the plausibilities of the world" (Burke) was the result of their atomization, of their loss of social status along with which they lost the whole sector of communal relationships in whose framework common sense makes sense. In their situation of spiritual and social homelessness, a measured insight into the interdependence of the arbitrary and the planned, the accidental and the necessary, could no longer operate. Totalitarian propaganda can outrageously insult common sense only where common sense has lost its validity. Before the alternative of facing the anarchic growth and total arbitrariness of decay or bowing down before the most rigid, fantastically fictitious consistency of an ideology, the masses probably will always choose the latter and be ready to pay for it with individual sacrifices—and this not because they are stupid or wicked, but because in the general disaster this escape grants them a minimum of self-respect.
From chapter "The Totalitarian Movement" in Hannah Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism. [my emphasis]
Showing posts with label hannah arendt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hannah arendt. Show all posts
21 October 2013
From Coincidence Into Consistency
Labels:
common sense,
consistency,
hannah arendt,
masses,
mystery,
Propaganda,
totalitarianism
17 June 2013
The Path to Chaos
I hope you had a nice Father's Day. Mine was blessed with the gift of multiple cheeses...what more can you want besides perhaps beer?
I've been thinking a bit more about "the mind of god/mind of man" issue that has been bouncing around in my head due to discussions about Louis Agassiz and perhaps Transcendentalism.
It has seemed to lead logically into Arendt's thinking on Totalitarianism.
Monocultures and Monotheism. A reaching after domination by a single idea and a single species. Knowing the mind of God; The mind of god is the mind of man is the mind of the universe is the highest being, etc.
I just finished reading a short book called The End of the Wild by Stephen Meyer to support my show on Rachel Carson's Silent Spring (what exactly can that "legacy" be when it seems to have only spawned partisan economics?). The End of the Wild points to the fact that all species which are surviving are only those "fitted" to live in man's orbit or wake. The environment continues to be reduced and will become a sameness.
Chaos is sameness, rather than what I think is the common misconception of it as crazy randomness (that is a better definition of fecundity, of life!).
The Bible is a testament to monoculture as well as monotheism. It is a giving up of all randomness to serve a single idea. The single idea is arbitrary but serving it is deeply logical. This leads to the rightness of murder and extermination of whole peoples and cultures. The Nazi idea of a "master" race logically justifies extermination of the lesser races primarily to try to guarantee a "clean" bloodline.
That is Arendt's Totalitarianism. This is the human perception of the human species. Dominion and Mind. The Bible seems to me then a description of the human mind as it comes to understand its arbitrary capacity for dominion. The IDEA is all that's needed.
Perhaps this terrifying logical outcome is unavoidable in the human: the chaos of the human as monoculture.
This, I think, is the drive to be entertained by vampires and zombies--we all know that we are superfluous when it comes to the IDEA and the arbitrary application of Power. Monocultures are not about individuals, not about freedom, not about rights...(neither are monotheisms by the way--that would more properly apply to the fecundity of pagan cultures). Just think of the words to realize the direction we're taking--monocultures lead to sterility.
What can we do if our "masses" are "superfluous" and their "belonging" is engaged by a terrible ideal? This seems too easy, easier and easier, in the daily "chaos," the sameness of experience encouraged by our tech-media cultures.
What is a "like" button and what does it serve?
I've been thinking a bit more about "the mind of god/mind of man" issue that has been bouncing around in my head due to discussions about Louis Agassiz and perhaps Transcendentalism.
It has seemed to lead logically into Arendt's thinking on Totalitarianism.
Monocultures and Monotheism. A reaching after domination by a single idea and a single species. Knowing the mind of God; The mind of god is the mind of man is the mind of the universe is the highest being, etc.
I just finished reading a short book called The End of the Wild by Stephen Meyer to support my show on Rachel Carson's Silent Spring (what exactly can that "legacy" be when it seems to have only spawned partisan economics?). The End of the Wild points to the fact that all species which are surviving are only those "fitted" to live in man's orbit or wake. The environment continues to be reduced and will become a sameness.
Chaos is sameness, rather than what I think is the common misconception of it as crazy randomness (that is a better definition of fecundity, of life!).
The Bible is a testament to monoculture as well as monotheism. It is a giving up of all randomness to serve a single idea. The single idea is arbitrary but serving it is deeply logical. This leads to the rightness of murder and extermination of whole peoples and cultures. The Nazi idea of a "master" race logically justifies extermination of the lesser races primarily to try to guarantee a "clean" bloodline.
That is Arendt's Totalitarianism. This is the human perception of the human species. Dominion and Mind. The Bible seems to me then a description of the human mind as it comes to understand its arbitrary capacity for dominion. The IDEA is all that's needed.
Perhaps this terrifying logical outcome is unavoidable in the human: the chaos of the human as monoculture.
This, I think, is the drive to be entertained by vampires and zombies--we all know that we are superfluous when it comes to the IDEA and the arbitrary application of Power. Monocultures are not about individuals, not about freedom, not about rights...(neither are monotheisms by the way--that would more properly apply to the fecundity of pagan cultures). Just think of the words to realize the direction we're taking--monocultures lead to sterility.
What can we do if our "masses" are "superfluous" and their "belonging" is engaged by a terrible ideal? This seems too easy, easier and easier, in the daily "chaos," the sameness of experience encouraged by our tech-media cultures.
What is a "like" button and what does it serve?
Labels:
chaos,
dominion,
end of the wild,
hannah arendt,
human,
logic,
Mind,
monoculture,
monotheism,
nazi,
rachel carson,
silent spring,
social media,
sterility,
steven meyer,
the bible,
totalitarianism,
weedy species
05 June 2013
A Progressive Experiment
“The angel of history”
I find my poems reveal "me" and reveal the stories that reside within me in ways that are surprising, but only if I give myself time to think about them; that is, to read and interpret my own accidental being in the moment of composition and consequently in the moment of interpretation. Sorry for that meta-me talk...but it seems highly necessary these days to see yourself as a particular agglomeration open to disciplined attempts at understanding as a process investigation. This is akin to saying of words that I put on paper, "Who wrote that?" or "What of that is true of me?" As might be obvious, those are difficult if not impossible questions to try to answer with anything close to certainty. If asked, "what did you mean to say?" I might be tempted to assert that I don't mean to say anything but the words seem to say something.
***
Below I excerpt stanzas from a longer piece, "test results," to illustrate my own compositional confusion as I try to discover the ways this condensed version spotlights a stronger and more dangerous interpretation.
furious chemicals will
impregnate political
flesh to embody the fates
they no longer remember
entangled in the specious
present their own history
described by the same quantum
mechanical description
which is indefinite in
terms of important factors
a treachery forgotten
in the course of thousands of
years, forgotten by the gods,
the eagles, forgotten by
the jew as metonymic
experimental subject
a rational example
yielding progressive results
***
The italicized words are out of Kafka.
***
What I wanted to offer here is something akin to that economic quip by that horrific man Milton Friedman, "we're all Keynesians now." Is it wrong for me to think of Friedman in the way I imagine Eichmann--a man who's thinking and justifications are excused by ostensible obeisance to the operations of a system one doesn't "control." That is a refusal of responsibility and an acceptance of following power as the correct, pragmatic, action.
***
One thing I mean to say is that what is visible to us culturally is often this very powerful and strange recurrence of narrative elements with often, again, visibly, a "representative" of the "storied" Jew in his storied guises. It's often inescapable AS story but too as real elements of our imaginary.
But here, that is in the poem, it is the Holocaust, the genocide, that "becomes us" and the Jew in the poem (as metonymic) stands in for the whole of us. Historically we are all in this relationship to extreme arbitrary power and our current mechanisms of state--primarily military and financial (or should I say as citizen-debtors), but also really all systems of sustenance and knowledge--make it extraordinarily easy to CREATE useful catastrophe wherein we are all subjects of experiment.
***
Himmler seems as readily characterized as an opportunistic businessman. A rather staid description for one committing genocide. But a key factor in much of what he perpetrated was how this human resource might be used to enrich him before liquidation.
***
So it is from this vantage point that we look back to the example of history. The narrative lessons of easy systematic eradication. Man's chemical fury is NOT effective on insects, but VERY effective on Man. That is "we are all jews now," objects to expunge without compunction--ie, un-beings. There is only power, and only what power can use or destroy.
And here is Arendt, corrective to the "man" Heidegger, and a furtherance of his best work but with greater human, relational, insight. An ethics of how we might correct "technicity" before it loads onto cattle cars (controlled remotely) all those useless to the paradigm "at large."
***
The full poem is dedicated to Rachel Carson, who wrote Silent Spring as a warning to us about the "banality" of our response to the chemical war on fundamental aspects of our ecology ("bugs" and "weeds" and people who are bugs and weeds to those who hold the spray nozzle), was incisive and clear and a deeply poetic writer.
But in the end the book, while certainly alarming, can be too readily minimized by the human ignorance of interconnectivity. Human chemical agency is like a billion-billion butterflies flapping their wings and altering the world. And it only weakly addresses the fact that human "control" mechanisms are imaginatively as "positive" as the economic realities of the human lives employed in this industry. We invest our being in our economic validation. Death-dealing is a livelihood.
***
In another context I heard that science, to some, can reveal God to Man, that with enough money, enough people seeking, we will find out the "mind" of God. This is a Progressive idea. It posits a Good that must (reasonably) be considered a Universal and then calculates the cost/benefit of achieving it. This might be considered a scrambled eggs utilitarianism promoted by those whose shells won't ever be cracked. That is, from the right perspective "experiment" will be justified. In fact, we like to say, as those do who praise and seek to justify military aggression in the Middle East, "time will vindicate us." That is, what seems like a terrorizing and murderous venture will be shown "in time" to have been an act of great benefit to "human freedoms." So perhaps, with the aid of passing solar revolutions, humans, if there are still humans, will make The Holocaust out to be a useful experiment for the species.
***
Or, perhaps, nothing is as hot when you eat it as when you cook it.
***
This poetic truncation seems a more powerful poem, but as I read this rendition (now a troubling term itself), it becomes arrestingly problematic in interpretation.
A procedure I use in many of my poems is to strip "location" from the text by eliminating the signs of direction...upper case, punctuation, enjambing lines that should be separate...in order to, as a friend has said (warned of), disconcert. I think of it as opening up interpretation. It's a kind of experiment in miscommunication.
In the full poem the "they" in stanza two is meant to refer to the chemicals (furious and fatal) and to render that fate via the political flesh that then applies those furies to other flesh--the Jewish victims of the Holocaust.
In this version, due to this lack of direction and this particular truncation, it reads something more like the familiar "blaming the victim" for treachery against God (the Kafka parable of Prometheus).
And that story too has been tested.
Where a chain of events appears to us, he sees one single catastrophe which keeps piling wreckage upon wreckage and hurls it in front of his feet. The angel would like to stay, awaken the dead, and join together what has been smashed to pieces….But a storm is blowing from Paradise [and] irresistibly propels him into the future to which his back is turned, while the pile of ruins before him grows skyward. What we call progress is this storm.”
Walter Benjamin quoted by Hannah Arendt***
I find my poems reveal "me" and reveal the stories that reside within me in ways that are surprising, but only if I give myself time to think about them; that is, to read and interpret my own accidental being in the moment of composition and consequently in the moment of interpretation. Sorry for that meta-me talk...but it seems highly necessary these days to see yourself as a particular agglomeration open to disciplined attempts at understanding as a process investigation. This is akin to saying of words that I put on paper, "Who wrote that?" or "What of that is true of me?" As might be obvious, those are difficult if not impossible questions to try to answer with anything close to certainty. If asked, "what did you mean to say?" I might be tempted to assert that I don't mean to say anything but the words seem to say something.
***
Below I excerpt stanzas from a longer piece, "test results," to illustrate my own compositional confusion as I try to discover the ways this condensed version spotlights a stronger and more dangerous interpretation.
furious chemicals will
impregnate political
flesh to embody the fates
they no longer remember
entangled in the specious
present their own history
described by the same quantum
mechanical description
which is indefinite in
terms of important factors
a treachery forgotten
in the course of thousands of
years, forgotten by the gods,
the eagles, forgotten by
the jew as metonymic
experimental subject
a rational example
yielding progressive results
***
The italicized words are out of Kafka.
***
What I wanted to offer here is something akin to that economic quip by that horrific man Milton Friedman, "we're all Keynesians now." Is it wrong for me to think of Friedman in the way I imagine Eichmann--a man who's thinking and justifications are excused by ostensible obeisance to the operations of a system one doesn't "control." That is a refusal of responsibility and an acceptance of following power as the correct, pragmatic, action.
***
One thing I mean to say is that what is visible to us culturally is often this very powerful and strange recurrence of narrative elements with often, again, visibly, a "representative" of the "storied" Jew in his storied guises. It's often inescapable AS story but too as real elements of our imaginary.
But here, that is in the poem, it is the Holocaust, the genocide, that "becomes us" and the Jew in the poem (as metonymic) stands in for the whole of us. Historically we are all in this relationship to extreme arbitrary power and our current mechanisms of state--primarily military and financial (or should I say as citizen-debtors), but also really all systems of sustenance and knowledge--make it extraordinarily easy to CREATE useful catastrophe wherein we are all subjects of experiment.
***
Himmler seems as readily characterized as an opportunistic businessman. A rather staid description for one committing genocide. But a key factor in much of what he perpetrated was how this human resource might be used to enrich him before liquidation.
***
So it is from this vantage point that we look back to the example of history. The narrative lessons of easy systematic eradication. Man's chemical fury is NOT effective on insects, but VERY effective on Man. That is "we are all jews now," objects to expunge without compunction--ie, un-beings. There is only power, and only what power can use or destroy.
And here is Arendt, corrective to the "man" Heidegger, and a furtherance of his best work but with greater human, relational, insight. An ethics of how we might correct "technicity" before it loads onto cattle cars (controlled remotely) all those useless to the paradigm "at large."
***
The full poem is dedicated to Rachel Carson, who wrote Silent Spring as a warning to us about the "banality" of our response to the chemical war on fundamental aspects of our ecology ("bugs" and "weeds" and people who are bugs and weeds to those who hold the spray nozzle), was incisive and clear and a deeply poetic writer.
But in the end the book, while certainly alarming, can be too readily minimized by the human ignorance of interconnectivity. Human chemical agency is like a billion-billion butterflies flapping their wings and altering the world. And it only weakly addresses the fact that human "control" mechanisms are imaginatively as "positive" as the economic realities of the human lives employed in this industry. We invest our being in our economic validation. Death-dealing is a livelihood.
***
In another context I heard that science, to some, can reveal God to Man, that with enough money, enough people seeking, we will find out the "mind" of God. This is a Progressive idea. It posits a Good that must (reasonably) be considered a Universal and then calculates the cost/benefit of achieving it. This might be considered a scrambled eggs utilitarianism promoted by those whose shells won't ever be cracked. That is, from the right perspective "experiment" will be justified. In fact, we like to say, as those do who praise and seek to justify military aggression in the Middle East, "time will vindicate us." That is, what seems like a terrorizing and murderous venture will be shown "in time" to have been an act of great benefit to "human freedoms." So perhaps, with the aid of passing solar revolutions, humans, if there are still humans, will make The Holocaust out to be a useful experiment for the species.
***
Or, perhaps, nothing is as hot when you eat it as when you cook it.
***
This poetic truncation seems a more powerful poem, but as I read this rendition (now a troubling term itself), it becomes arrestingly problematic in interpretation.
A procedure I use in many of my poems is to strip "location" from the text by eliminating the signs of direction...upper case, punctuation, enjambing lines that should be separate...in order to, as a friend has said (warned of), disconcert. I think of it as opening up interpretation. It's a kind of experiment in miscommunication.
In the full poem the "they" in stanza two is meant to refer to the chemicals (furious and fatal) and to render that fate via the political flesh that then applies those furies to other flesh--the Jewish victims of the Holocaust.
In this version, due to this lack of direction and this particular truncation, it reads something more like the familiar "blaming the victim" for treachery against God (the Kafka parable of Prometheus).
And that story too has been tested.
Labels:
banality,
chemistry,
franz kafka,
hannah arendt,
heidegger,
History,
Poetry,
progressivism,
rachel carson,
science,
the holocaust,
Walter Benjamin
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)